Source Comparison
Compare three sources on whether remote work reduces or increases productivity
No card required
What this brief specifies
Audience
This comparison feeds an HR committee that's deciding the company's return-to-office policy.
The sources
Three sources are in play: a 2015 academic field study, a 2023 economics paper analyzing workplace data, and a 2024 industry work-trend report, spanning almost a decade.
The tension
The three sources appear to give contradictory answers about whether remote work helps or hurts productivity.
What makes this hard
The three sources here don't just disagree, they disagree while differing in method and in when they were run, which means the disagreement itself needs explaining before the comparison is useful to anyone. One is a controlled field study, one is an econometric analysis of workplace data, and one is a survey-based industry report, three different ways of measuring the same underlying question, and they span nearly a decade, 2015 to 2024, a period spanning the shift into and out of the pandemic that changed what remote work even looked like in practice. So when the sources reach different conclusions, that could mean the earlier study no longer describes how remote work is actually practiced now, or it could mean the methods themselves are measuring different things and were never going to agree. An HR committee writing a return-to-office policy off the back of this needs to know which explanation is true, because averaging three incompatible answers into one recommendation would produce a policy nobody can actually defend.
Related use cases
See how Flaibo works for Legal Pro.
Frequently asked questions
The next policy decision that has to be justified against sources that disagree benefits from a comparison that explains why they disagree, a method difference or a real shift in the underlying situation, rather than one that quietly blends conflicting answers into a single number and calls it consensus.